Books

The Celle Seminars – Page 126

Sulphuratum. It says: aversion to company, irritable, especially to friends; mental exhaustion; mental exerting aggravates strongly; exertion and motion aggravate; loss of hair and heat. I think it fits.(A.6): I have another idea. He mentioned a fear of dogs, at least I understood it that way. He also mentioned a number of modali-ties, like amelioration in the dark. This all leads me to think of Stramonium.
(G.V.): Well, I think you went too far. You assumed certain things in the case that are not there. There is no fear of dogs. He said he was once bitten by a dog and that he may indeed be afraid if some big dog were to attack him. But I wonder if anybody in the room wouldn’t be afraid in a similar situation! So, you can’t count this as symptom. Fear of animals is a symptom when you have a little puppy in your room and somebody opens the door, sees the puppy, and then runs out. That’s fear of dogs. If a ferocious dog attacks, I don’t believe that anybody would be very cool, unless he is specially trained. Therefore, we do not have real fear of violence or fear of dogs here, nor do we have a real fear of the dark like we see in Stramonium.
In order to tackle a case, to understand a case, we have to see it in the right context. We must grasp the most important aspects of the case and then think of remedies with similar symptoma-tology. We also have to ask ourselves, “What is important for this particular organism?” One might say that his skin eruptions are the most important thing. What do you feel when you see this patient? His itching causes him to suffer, therefore it is only natural that you should feel that his suffering is expressed on a psychological level. You may see someone with alopecia who is quite happy. Or you might see someone who is paralyzed and also quite happy. The connection often made, namely, that he has a problem and is therefore justified in being unhappy, is some-times a mistaken conjunction. Although the patient’s problems became apparent after receiving Sulphur – he began to lose his hair – I don’t believe that his psychological state is a result of this hair loss. Instead, I think his psychological state must have been