Books

Materia Medica Viva – Volume 2 page 494

without being able to remember what they had been looking for. A moment’s pause is needed to rethink the whole process, after which memory returns. This sudden loss of memory overcomes minds that are worn with cares and problems; these people have many things on their minds and very little mental power. Eventually a point is reached where even talking is a greatly bothersome task.
The mere effort of speaking out their minds can have the effect of aggravating the physical situation of Argentum metallicum. Kent writes: "if compelled to answer he becomes dizzy, and feels strange all over, and has nervous shakes or shocks." You must be able to imagine the kind of weakness experienced by your patient if such symptoms can arise just from the mere effort of talking. Not only the voice, but the chest, the respiratory system, indeed the whole organism is affected. At this point we may make a comparison with some other remedies, beginning withStannum : Stannum complains of the chest being so weak that the voice will not come out; Arg-met. has a general aggravation of the organism from talking, but also from the psychological effort involved in answering questions. Stannum is depressed, physically and mentally tired on talking, whereas Arg-met. pushes himself to answer and in the effort becomes excited and at the same time tired. Mur-ac. is very tired generally, so tired that he cannot even talk. Sepia is tired but mostly not interested in communicating, and therefore talking. Phos-ac. is indifferent and mentally tired, therefore he will not talk.
Be on your guard, therefore, when a patient, in relating his case to you, says in passing: "I am even tired to talk". Try to elucidate the type of tiredness you are dealing with. Does it fit the Stannum tiredness, the Mur-acid tiredness, the Sepia tiredness, the Phos-acid or is it indeed the Arg-met. tiredness?
This state is accompanied by anxiety about their condition, and often by the impression of an imminent brain stroke. The tiredness engenders depression where all they want is to lie down in an isolated room. There is no emotional stamina left to deal with social contact and communication.
The overexcitement of the mind gives way to dulness, difficulty in thinking and depression. This is a forerunner of a manic-depressive condition that may develop later on in life. Then they present overexcitement, with rapid talking, nonsensical prattling reaching a wild stage where they cannot be restrained, even hitting out and striking