Books

Materia Medica Viva – Volume 2 page 473

indication alone, as Burnett suggests, will very seldom give satisfactory results, I think. On the other hand, these two cases confirm that this keynote is quite correct (and should not be disputed); were it not, the remedy would have had no effect at all in either of the cases.
Allen writes in his Handbook : "It has been found useful for asthma with spasmodic cough at night, in general worse lying. Spasmodic cough at night, after the first sleep, cough caused by tickling in throat associated with constriction of chest, has to sit up and cough violently."
You will see satisfactory results with this remedy in cases in which during the initial years the common colde start with an acrid coryza; red, dry, parched lips; and an aggravation from cold air. These acute cases look like Arsenicum album. You prescribe Arsenicum, and the cold travels rapidly into the bronchii while the coryza lessens impressively. This is a bad sign, and your immediate assumption should be that either the patient’s constitution is weak or that the remedy was wrong.
At night the patient wakes up after a short sleep with violent spasmodic coughing that eventually forces him to get up from bed; he then sits and coughs for some time before he can go back to sleep. He needs his head high to prevent coughing. You think that this is an aggravation from the Arsenicum, and you wait, but the next night is worse. This is the time that this small remedy must be given, if one is fortunate enough to remember it and to include it in one’s armamentarium.
The respiratory condition is almost always worse on lying down at night, and even more characteristic is an aggravation after a short sleep. The patient, even in the beginning of the night, will ask to sleep with a thick pillow. He wakes up with spasmodic coughing which is followed by difficult respiration. Tough, stringy mucus seems to obstruct the air passages, and he soon finds that he has to get up and walk around or sit up in bed to relieve the situation. Sitting bent forward ameliorates the coughing or the dyspnea.
There is violent spasmodic coughing, aggravated around midnight, but in some cases the condition will last until the early morning, 3 or 4 a.m. The same time modalities apply to the dyspnea.
A combination frequently seen is: tickling in the throat; loud, wheezing respiration, spasmodic cough, difficult breathing, all are aggravated before or around midnight. The expectoration is warm and has a salty taste.