with Sulphur or with Calcarea. I think I would most probably begin with Sulphur.
(G.V.): Calcarea was given already in a potency of 10M.
(A.8): Another objective symptom is that he talks and shouts in his sleep. Therefore, you can use the rubric talking excitedly while asleep, which would be Sulphur.
(A.9): I feel he is a very closed person; that’s the impression one gets. And he seems to be more compassionate towards other people than he is towards himself. There are three main rem-edies that I thought of in this case which are Natrum muriaticum, Causticum and Kali carbonicum.
(A.10): This is a long standing case involving many different sorts of medications. It seemed important to know which symp-toms he developed most recently. The most recent symptom seems to be the biting of the fingernails.
(G.V.): He bites his fingers, not his nails. You remember me ask-ing why he had adhesive bandages on his two fingers; he said it was to prevent him from biting his fingers when in pain. We could not determine whether this afforded him any relief from the pain. Most likely the pain just gets so annoying that he has to do something to take his mind off it.
(A.11): Because his bladder and peripheral extremities are affected, I would prefer Causticum. But when I thought of the problems with his right arm and left leg and his oily face, along with the impression I got of him as a mentally bland and passive person, I began to prefer Causticum as a remedy.
(A.12): I found one symptom that points to Causticum which is excited while debating.
(G.V.): It is really interesting that no one has mentioned Tubercu-linum in this case, in spite of the fact that we know that the origin of his illness is definitely tubercular because of tuberculosis. You were all correct in passing over this remedy because, although we have a clear causative factor, we do not see Tuberculinum symptoms here. We do not have enough information about Tuberculinum. All we can do is keep this remedy in the back of