of India; a government position, a very authoritative woman, she was like a man. She had been treated by the best homeopaths in India, with no effect. She had a liver problem that was so severe that an ascites would come on suddenly and her whole body would swell up; her arm would almost double in size. She had two dresses, one for the time when she swelled up, and the other for when she went down. She came to be treated, and I took the case; underneath I saw this Pulsatilla element I told her to take Pulsatilla, and she immediately went to the homeopaths who were treating her in Delhi and told them that “George has given me Pulsatilla She later told me how the doctors reacted, all of them said: “You Pulsatilla? Never!” “Yes,” she replied, “outside I have to appear to be strong, but inside maybe I’m not that strong at all.” She took Pulsatilla and she was cured. The main thing is that they had tried treating her for sixteen years with every remedy except Pulsatilla, but no one had been able to find the correct remedy. This just goes to show that you cannot replace one remedy with another.
(A.): Don’t we have to differentiate in this acute case of pneumo-nia between the acute phase and the chronic mental state which might be another remedy?
(G.V.): Correct, but then we come to the next question: Is this a Pulsatilla upon which pneumonia has been imprinted, or can it be a pneumonia state that is different from the underlying remedy? This is the main question because of certain charac-teristics, for instance, she said that she was constantly losing urine, and, because of being worse from warmth and things like that, we may suppose that this pneumonia state was carried on from a previous state, and this acute phase just produced a more prominent Pulsatilla case. We just don’t know at this point; we cannot really be sure until we see the results reflected in what is happening in her life and the changes that are taking place after the remedy. Still, for me, this woman’s personality can be Pulsa-tillaa, because the sweet, affectionate element is there. She may be conformed and closed so a Kali element, Kali sulphuricum