a very strong symptom. I go to the repertory and I look up “dry cough, worse lying down,” and I see the important remedies there. If you go and look this up in your repertory, you’ll see two remedies in capitals: Hyoscyamus and Pulsatilla. In the course of the interrogation she talks about a meaningless cough during the whole day, but in the morning after – she explained this logi-cally – the negative effect (as she calls it) of the remedy, she has some expectoration. So now instead of going to the repertory you should go to materia medica. If you read Pulsatilla in the materia medica, you will see that Pulsatilla has a dry cough that becomes loose in the morning and lasts for the rest of the day as a dry cough without expectoration.
Her description of the cough was what brought me to the correct remedy. In the meantime I asked about warm and cold: she is a warm person, she is aggravated by warm. Instinctively she says that what she needs is cold, but perhaps because of her condition she applies hot. Why does she apply hot? Because of the Kali carbonicum, which chills her down and changes the symptoma-tology a little bit. That is the problem with this case: it is not clear, it is confused, and therefore the Pulsatilla element does not come through very strongly. What she wants is open windows and also affection. Despite the fact that she says she wants to be by herself, it is still nice, she says, to receive affection from someone. What confirms the diagnosis now? Well, you have for one: on coughing, loss of urine. You’ll see Pulsatilla in capitals as well there. So, if you have two symptoms underlined three times, like “cough lying on the back,” then you have to see the remedy in capitals; “coughing, loses urine” also has to be in capitals. In both these main symptoms Pulsatilla is capital, therefore the remedy must be Pulsatilla.
Do you see why I took so long in this case, why I thought so much and put things all together? For the simple reason that I have to be correct on the first remedy. I especially do not have the luxury here of being wrong and giving several different remedies until I hit upon the right one, and that’s why I take so