second one and the coughing, that particular type of coughing, the feeling here (points to the throat) and in the stomach was so intense that I couldn’t possibly have taken the third remedy.
LIVE
(G.V.): Do you understand what is happening? You see, Kali carbonicum has a feeling in the stomach which is very annoy-ing: it is like a kind of fear arising from the stomach, or as if the stomach has been hit hard and is in a state of stress. In general, Kali carbonicum centers very much upon the secretions of the stomach. What happened is that by taking Kali carbonicum cer-tain symptoms of this remedy were produced upon her, and now she relates these symptoms together with the original symptoms. Therefore, if you want to find the remedy, you should not go to this symptom, which she relates after taking the Kali carboni-cum, but rather to the original symptom, the main symptom – dry cough aggravated by lying down – this has to be a very strong leading symptom. So far the case is not clear at all. Except for this symptom, there are no real symptoms to guide you.
VIDEO
(G.V.): Does motion make it worse, movement, yes or no?
(F.P.): Yes it does.
LIVE
(G.V.): Motion makes it worse. You see, I’m thinking of Bryonia. I asked a straight question – Does motion makes it worse? – and I received an answer; how would you interpret it? I asked a ques-tion concerning Bryonia and in order for me to confirm Bryonia the answer should have been, “Oh yes, the least little motion!” An answer that strong and precise would make it a case of Bryonia, otherwise I have to turn to other remedies that are worse from motion. For Bryonia, which is so much worse from motion, I have to have a strong enough reply. How did she answer? Let’s