Books

The Bern Seminars – Page 12

Calcarea carbonica with an underlying Tuberculinum. The manifestation of the symptomatology in this case is going to be different from the manifestation of the symptomatology in a case of Calcarea carbonica with an underlying Medorrhinum. The underlying remedy can often color the patient’s symptomatol-ogy; then we have another type of a case, one involving layers. In cases involving different layers, the first thing we will notice is that the picture of the remedy is not clear. For instance, sup-pose you perceive the possibility of several different remedies in a case, and you ask yourself: can this be Pulsatilla? Yes, but what about Sulphur? It has the symptomatology of Sulphur, but it also resembles Calcarea carbonica in this aspect and there is also a possibility of Cuprum, and some Nitricum acidum or Argentum nitricum is there as well! Then we are lost. You might say that the prognosis in such a case is not good, perhaps only so-so at best, because you do not see the results that you saw in the first, more clear-cut case. Having given the remedy and not seeing a significant effect might make you feel discouraged. You might doubt your ability as a homeopath. Why? Because it’s a matter of “similia similibus curentur.”
Take the remedy Arnica for example: it works beautifully on bruises, but you might see cases in which you give Arnica for bruises and they do not go away. Of course you can give the patient more Arnica, but it will not speed up the healing process; besides, the bruises will go away by themselves in two months or so anyway! The problem in such a case is that the remedy is not the similimum.
Bruises like those I’ve just described would require Sulphu-ricum acidum, not Arnica. Sulphuricum acidum was indicated, but we just could not see it. This example of Arnica shows again the importance of searching through the many layers in a case.
You all must have experienced cases in which it seems that you gave almost everything possible – Natrum muriaticum, Pulsatilla, and still saw no result. Suppose, given such a case, your patient were to come in one day and say, “all my problems