Books

Materia Medica Viva Volume 1 – Page 161

confused as if the mind is under the influence of a lot of barbiturates, yawning all the time, sleepy and disinterested. In writing he makes a lot of mistakes in spelling, misplaces words etc. But remember that the sleepy brain is the main idea behind the symptomatology. Sleepiness with indifference.
This is very much in accordance with the pathogenesis of this remedy, as the onion was known in ancient times to be a hypnagogic, and has been used for sleeplessness since then. It is peculiar that in our Materia Medica this element is not mentioned in the provings. If anybody eats a lot of onions the first thing he will experience will be sleepiness. Because of this quality of affecting the brain the ancients were actually afraid of using onions in excess.
There is another state to which Allium cepa can move and this is a very serious mental state: the patient may look quite well, but suddenly he may have a disappointment, or he may be offended by something, with the result that the mind is totally thrown out of balance. Following this we see a state of real insanity, a totally passive insanity where the brain does not function at all.
It is a state that can come suddenly in a person who was very balanced before, very conscientious, very meticulous in his cleaning habits, with a lot of warm feelings for his relatives, very sympathetic; he really cared about others. A straight mind that did not hide, was not devious. And suddenly this behaviour changes from one day to another: he does not recognise persons he knew very well before and is totally indifferent towards persons who live with him, like his wife or his parents. He does not understand the meaning of things. You give him money and he does not know what it is. Never mind how much you explain to him what to do, he does not comprehend. It seems that the only thing he wants to do is to go to sleep. He sleeps and sleeps and it is very difficult to wake him up. He goes from a chair to bed and from the bed to the chair, and falls immediately in a deep soporous sleep. He is lethargic. When you hear such a story and you do not know the mental picture of Allium cepa you will tend to give Opium or Nux-moschata, but Allium cepa fits this mental pathology better. It is interesting that in our books Allium cepa is mentioned in insanity, but nowhere could I find any indication of the type of insanity.
He makes foolish grimaces, foolish gestures and in general his behaviour becomes foolish. He may tease a stranger in the street by making some ridiculous gesture, for instance while travelling in a train he